SPOILER Alison alive ?

Do you think it was the real Ali at the end of Killer ? Bcuz she didn't recognize he girls , that's weird ....

I think it was her, or if it wasn't her, it might have been a twin?

That was very weird, Alison not recognizing them. I don't think it could be her twin - that would be too complicated. Ali has had a history of strange behavior though, like staring off into space and changing emotions quickly (for example, sitting on the couch during Ian and Spencer's talk show, when she was talking about losing her flag). I think it's possible that Ali is A. It explains why she was in the woods; she was spying on the girls. It also explains why the new A is helping the girls and giving them clues rather than hurting them.

Any other ideas ???

but if it was ali who is a whos body was found in there back yard and where would she have been hiding for three years.

In the Ponocos house ?

prettylittleliarsaholic wrote:but if it was ali who is a whos body was found in there back yard and where would she have been hiding for three years.

i think it was Ali in the woods. im thinking jason killed someone, and they had to cover it up some how. so they made up the story that the body was Ali. because the reason they new it was her was because of the ring she was wearing remember? they would have just put it on the body. and ya probably in the Ponocos house. and she was probably in the house when aria went to see jason cause jason was freaking out and asking if she went in the main house.

I think it might be her. If it is her, then she might have hit her head and gotten amnesia? (Ok, that's a little old, but it still could have happened.) Or maybe she was so scared and so happy she was saved that she wasn't really looking at them? Or maybe she just didn't recognize them, as they're so much older now? IDK, but I think it might be her.

But again, if it is Ali, then how can we explain the body they found in the backyard? Since they recognized her by the ring, it could have been someone wearing her ring. But that means they would have had to kill someone else, and there weren't any other suspicious disappearances around the time of Ali's, were there?

I don't know who the girl is, but I can't wait to find out!!!!

Yeah if ali is Alive who is THE body then ?good question becca ...

i think that the girl that aria saved was ali and that A IS NOT ALI because ali got a note saying to go into the woods that night... humm.... and idk about the body in the ground..... isnt all pretty darn wierd.... i think that the reason ali ''didnt reconise them'' is not a reason at all. i think that she knew her face was covered in ash so she looked up and hoped that THEY didnt reconise her so she pretended not to know them!!!!
it could happen....

I'm really curious about if it was ali or not . And if it's not Ali then Sara shepard must be a genius to write another plotline to explain it wasn't her !

pllsweetie wrote:i think that the girl that aria saved was ali and that A IS NOT ALI because ali got a note saying to go into the woods that night... humm.... and idk about the body in the ground..... isnt all pretty darn wierd.... i think that the reason ali ''didnt reconise them'' is not a reason at all. i think that she knew her face was covered in ash so she looked up and hoped that THEY didnt reconise her so she pretended not to know them!!!!
it could happen....

Does anyone remember the girls looking strait at the dead body in the hole or did they only see the blonde hair? Because all I can remember is them seeing the blonde hair and someone could easily fake that. But like Ian's possibly faked death maybe they faked her death too.

the body in the whole couldnt even have blond hair because it was in the ground for three whole years!!!!!!!

organicpeaches wrote:Does anyone remember the girls looking strait at the dead body in the hole or did they only see the blonde hair? Because all I can remember is them seeing the blonde hair and someone could easily fake that. But like Ian's possibly faked death maybe they faked her death too.

I thought they didnt see the body at all ...

yeah, police wouldnt let a bounch of teen age girls see there dead friends body, would the girls even want to see it? i dont think so....

but i thought maya was like "they were digging up the cement and i saw the blonde hair" but maybe im wrong i thought i heard them saying something about blonde hair

oh... well idk i dont remember!!!!!!!!!

I think that it was Ali. Since Wilden was the main cop investigating the case and he was acting strange he may have lied and said it was Ali in the hole and it wasn't. Maybe Jason or Ian would check on Ali in the woods or wherever she could have been hiding? I don't know, the ending was very unexpected.

i dont think the blond hair thing is possible. i mean... "she" was under the ground for 3 years. wouldnt the hair be REALLY dirty and brown?? or even decomposted?

I've pretty much dedicated the free moments in Pre-Calculus class to debating about this, after I finished Unbelievable for the second time. First of all, there is something to be said about the amnesia. It is highly possible that Wilden and Jason were pretty much involved, but we could also be dealing with a whole new A and that this girl, who appears to be Ali, could in fact be her, but tied in another way.

(Bless Sara and her ability to keep us looped xD)

Although, I think that the night of Alison's murder could have been a tragic accident that Jason attempted to cover up. Ian could have confronted someone else, or Jason for that matter, with a horrific ending that Ali walked in on (or she AND Ian walked in on, thus tying them in). The cover up could have been made, but that brings in the question: Why is Ian still around for when Unbelievable sets in, and why would Ali fake her death?

Either she is dead and the girl's were probably confused, or whats bubbling under the surface is bigger than we can imagine.

Either is fine with me xD.

organicpeaches wrote:but i thought maya was like "they were digging up the cement and i saw the blonde hair" but maybe im wrong i thought i heard them saying something about blonde hair

nope they didnt see any hair, her body was all decomposed. they knew it was ali because of her ring.. but you never know if the DNA tests were true or not. Someone could of put that ring on that body and the body could be someone elses..

Ali is dead to me.... i honestly think she's dead i mean sure there is some weird stuff but then when you think about it makes sense...


shes dead

i think there are 5 people in the Dilunertis ( how eer u spell it family..
theres mom and dad, jason, and 2 alis. i think the 2 alis switched off and on when hanging out with friends, and one ali did something horried so the family never spoke of them. then, mean ali 1 told nice ali 2 that she had to meet up with Ian that night to see what he said, break up with melissa or ali 1 would tell veryone about ian and her. so when ali 2 went to go to see ian, ian got really upset bc maybe ali 2 wuoldent kiss him or omething like that, then killed nice ali, and ali came running out bc she heard screaming, then ali saw her as he was throwing her sister in the hole, thn mean ali ran into the woods andnever came out. that also explains the ring bc they would have the saem inteicals.
makesa sence to me.. tell me what u think!

ariaemilyhannaspencer wrote:i think there are 5 people in the Dilunertis ( how eer u spell it family..
theres mom and dad, jason, and 2 alis. i think the 2 alis switched off and on when hanging out with friends, and one ali did something horried so the family never spoke of them. then, mean ali 1 told nice ali 2 that she had to meet up with Ian that night to see what he said, break up with melissa or ali 1 would tell veryone about ian and her. so when ali 2 went to go to see ian, ian got really upset bc maybe ali 2 wuoldent kiss him or omething like that, then killed nice ali, and ali came running out bc she heard screaming, then ali saw her as he was throwing her sister in the hole, thn mean ali ran into the woods andnever came out. that also explains the ring bc they would have the saem inteicals.
makesa sence to me.. tell me what u think!

i totally agree with that i think there were two that were twins and they would trade off, ones alive and one isnt and theyve been hiding the one that is alive like when aria went into jasons apartment and he got super mad...he could have been hiding something or someone in this case. and then when ally was in the woods maybe she couldnt remember anything but that idk...

ok, so, i think ALSO the new ali could be trying to kill the girls, i mean think about it:
they probly ruined her life somehow
she wants revenge
she probly hates them!!!

so maby thats what this new A is bout. maybe it is ali, but i dont think her name is ali, i think that her name was something diferent, like Alice, or Angie, or Angle.
something along those lines..
oh! and wasent Spencer suposed to be alis twin or somrthing..?

ariaemilyhannaspencer wrote:ok, so, i think ALSO the new ali could be trying to kill the girls, i mean think about it:
they probly ruined her life somehow
she wants revenge
she probly hates them!!!

so maby thats what this new A is bout. maybe it is ali, but i dont think her name is ali, i think that her name was something diferent, like Alice, or Angie, or Angle.
something along those lines..
oh! and wasent Spencer suposed to be alis twin or somrthing..?

Spencer wasn't her twin, but they are half sisters. They share the same father.
But I think Ali has a twin. A lot of the clues have pointed to that and it would help explain a lot of things. Sara has written the books amazingly.